One of the earliest homesteaders on the island was a man named Hugh McPhie. He arrived in America from Scotland in the late 1880s and, in 1899, McPhie was granted the third patent on the
Murder in Paradise: Galloway Murders on Fort Myers Beach (1953)
Dated: May 12 2021
On September 2, 1953, Ted “Carl” Smiddy was hitchhiking near Atlanta, Georgia shortly after being released from jail in Tennessee for breaking and entering and larceny. Smiddy was only 16 years old when he was picked up by Ernest Walter Moore, a convicted murderer who served ten years in an Ohio State prison before being paroled. Moore presented himself as a professional gambler to impress Smiddy. He showed Smiddy a wad of cash and promised him a job when they got to Miami. Smiddy gladly accepted the ride and was impressed by his new found friend.
The duo began their trip South making Jacksonville their first stop. They began their crime spree by robbing a Jacksonville motel of about $7.00. Continuing south to St. Augustine, the pair robbed a house where they stole some jewelry and clothing. When they arrived in Miami, the men broke into another house and stole a .32 caliber automatic. Moore and Smiddy left Miami and headed for the West Coast where they ended up on Fort Myers Beach.
While Moore and Smiddy were making their way to Estero Island, Jim and Mary Galloway were enjoying a quiet evening at home. The Galloways had recently built a new home on the beach front in the newly developed Island Shores subdivision at the north end of the island (near Bowditch today). In 1953, the beach front houses were few and far between, which was the main reason that the murderers chose to rob the Galloway house on the evening of September 5.
Jim and Mary were a very popular couple on the island. They came to the Beach from Detroit in 1948 where they managed the Mermaid Club. In the 1950s, the Mermaid Club was located on Estero Blvd where the Whale restaurant is presently located. Jim and Mary Galloway were very involved with the community as Jim was chairman of the anti-incorporation committee and Mary was a correspondent for the News-Press.
When Jim Galloway heard a knock on his door that September evening, he probably did not think twice before he opened the door. After all, Fort Myers Beach was a safe, quiet island, far from the crimes of a larger city. Unfortunately, when the door was opened, Moore put the gun in Galloway’s face and took his wallet. He made Galloway sit in a chair where he tied him up and hit him over the head with a large whiskey bottle.
Smiddy, in the meantime, was frightened by what Moore was doing, so he hid behind the door. Smiddy told the police that he was hiding when he heard Mary Galloway scream followed by a gunshot. After killing Jim and Mary, Moore told Smiddy to go to the car. Moore then went to Galloway’s private bar and had a few drinks before he splashed gas all over the house and set it on fire. The murderers took off in a stolen car with $81.00.
What happened next was pure luck. As Moore and Smiddy were heading to Fort Myers, Russell Garris, a Florida State Trooper, noticed a car with a broken headlight. Garris pulled the car over for what he thought was a normal traffic stop. However, as soon as he got out of his patrol car, Moore jumped out of the car and started shooting at Garris who took a bullet in the thigh before be got off six shots, hitting Moore in the chest and head. Smiddy, meanwhile, was once again hiding in the front seat of the car.
Moore was taken to Lee Memorial Hospital where he died two hours later. Smiddy was taken into custody where he told the police that Moore had given him a .38 caliber gun and told him to start shooting as well. Smiddy refused to take the gun and hunkered down in the car while Moore and Garris exchanged gunfire.
At the time of the arrest, the police were unaware of the connection between these men and the Galloway murders and house fire. It did not take long, however, for Smiddy to confess to the Galloway
Smiddy was tried twice in Lee County but was never convicted. The first trial was declared a mistrial when the jury could not reach a verdict. The second trial was also a mistrial when the attorneys could not agree on a jury. The case was then moved to Sarasota where the jury deliberated for over five hours before handing down two verdicts of manslaughter and sentenced Smiddy to two ten year sentences of hard labor at Raiford. Smiddy was transferred to the Apalachee Correctional Institute where he escaped in 1955. He turned himself in that same day and died in 1985.
Ellie has returned to real estate sales after spending the last 40 years teaching English at Florida SouthWestern State College in Fort Myers She has teamed up with her husband, Bob, who has been a....
Latest Blog Posts
On September 2, 1953, Ted “Carl” Smiddy was hitchhiking near Atlanta, Georgia shortly after being released from jail in Tennessee for breaking and entering and larceny.